Hand-Tossed & Handcrafted

Welcome to Henry & Eli's on Fitzpatrick Square

Historical Places

Fitzpatrick Street & Pirate's Alley

112 Fitzpatrick Street Key West, FL

Our Street 1829:

We are located on Fitzpatrick Street in Old Town Key West.  Never heard of it?  Well you're about to get a lot of future trivia knowledge on why our street is so important to Key West.  

On a side note, it is one of the only streets in Key West that is still paved in the original brick, which definitely means it is instagram worthy

Richard Fitzpatrick played a vital role in the economic and political life when he came to Key West in 1822 at the age of thirty.  Fitzpatrick immediately became one of the foremost citizens of the small town.  When William AdeeWhitehead finished surveying the island and laying out the town in February, 1829, streets were named after friends and relations of the original proprietors.  Fitzpatrick was the only prominent citizen of Key West after which a street was named. 

Read more


Pizza and beer is the perfect combination for movie night, game day parties and the classic college date night.  

But what if we told you, we could elevate your pizza and beer experience? Imagine knowing which beer would compliment the crust, sauce and topping options of your pizza. 

Get ready to take your pizza and beer game to the next level. We build our pizzas from scratch by making fresh pizza dough and sauce daily.  

During this event, you will enjoy different styles of hand-tossed pizza crafted just for you, by Chef Scott Grubb. We will pair each pizza slice with the perfect craft beer to enhance the flavor profile of both the beer and pizza.  

You will become an expert on how to turn your ordinary pizza night 

into a work of culinary art! 


Join Chef Scott Grubb

Pizza & Beer Pairings: 

Sausage and Mushroom Pizza 

Hand sliced italian sausage, fresh mushrooms, roasted garlic gloves, and mozzarella


Dogfish Head Craft Brewery

Seafood Pizza

Garlic and olive oil sauce, shrimp, scallops, crab, and mozzarella


Casa Modelo Mexican Beer

Modelo Especial 

Grecian Pizza

Garlic and olive oil sauce, grilled chicken, spinach, feta, and mozzarella

Florida Keys Breweing Company

Iguana Bait

Margherita Pizza

Fresh basil, roma tomato, buffalo mozzarella and parmesan


Island Coastal Lager


"Presented by Henry and Eli’s 

Side Street Pub"  

2:00pm - 4:00pm

112 Fitzpatrick Street

$40.00 per person

Buy Tickets